The Latest Al-Reuters Smear
June 7th, 2006 at 11:40 am by SmantixDue to the time it takes to write a post, you can never say with absolute certainty that you’re going to get “the latest” al-Reuters smear but this one is close enough from Reuters Iraqi Bureau Chief Alistair MacDonald:
TRAINED KILLERS
And it is not that Marines like those under suspicion at Haditha do not like fighting. They are trained to kill and, usually within the bounds of discipline, seem to relish combat.
“C’mon captain, Kilo’s getting all my kills!” a Reuters reporter heard one lament to his commander in Karabila last year as another unit stormed house-to-house in what an officer described with relish as “old school, door-to-door fighting.”
Says an unnamed Reuters reporter about what an unnamed Marine said.
Marines take a perverse pride in a sense of themselves as the Army’s poor relation in terms of budget, equipment and manpower. Many exude a bravado about taking greater risks than an Army with whom inter-service rivalry borders on hostility.
[...]
The martial spirit is instilled from the top down — one colonel told men before battle in Karabila: “There’s a lot of knuckleheads here who have to get dead. I’m going to help them.”Indeed for many Marines, who love their guns, what they hate most about the war in Iraq is not fighting — and especially not being able to fight back when their friends are killed.
Somebody grab a leash before these kill crazies rampage through the nursery school!
“Why won’t he come out and fight?” asked another as the squad chafed under their sergeant’s discipline and his demands they treat Iraqis whose homes they were searching with respect.
“… Iraqis, they’re so … ungrateful,” one young Marine said, peppering his speech with expletives. “I … hate them.”Another man snapped: “He killed my best friend,” he yelled. “It’s not fair. I’m not playing this game any more.” The Marine opened fire. Everyone froze. The dog that was his target lived.
No one died that day. The bonding of men at war is vital to any army and Marines place great stress on it. But their commander General Michael Hagee was recently in Iraq to remind them to keep emotions in check as Iraq continues to test the limits of the U.S. military.
“We use lethal force only when justified,” Hagee said.
“This is the American way of war.”
MacDonald is quite intuitive for as many unnamed sources as he uses. “The American way of war” gets a creative treatment by the Reuters’ Bureau Chief as an undisciplined group of borderline mutinous dog killers who can’t wait to kill some innocent, ungrateful Iraqis.
Small wonder with as many of MacDonald’s “reporters” getting confused with the terrorists themselves that this organization is rotting from the top down.










June 7th, 2006 at 4:23 pm
Someone from the real, adult world please inform Alistair McDonald that the Marines are involved in a very complicated combat/policing engagement. With an enemy that is largely indistinguishable from the civilians, and who has no problem killing his fellow Iraqis. Those Marines are held on a very tight leash so as to allow the Iraqis to mend their society as best they can.
Remember that the enemy is an organized and ruthless one that hides behind civilians and Rueters reporters, and his warring methods are very effective–Especially when guarded by the Chamberlin-esque posing of children like Alistair McDonald.
The Marines could end the fight in 90 days. Many civilians would die and the US would be guily of untold horrors. But the fight would end. Or the tyrants and terrorists could give up. And the fight would end. Which will it be, and which should it be Mr. McDonald?
Dan Patterson
Arrogant Infidel
June 7th, 2006 at 7:39 pm
Instapunk had a great line in a post about his father a few days ago along that same train of thought.
June 7th, 2006 at 10:23 pm
Marines In Iraq…
Smantix from Six Meat Buffet has a post up today that analyzes the Reuters coverage of the Marines / the military in Iraq. Give the post a read and see if you think Smantixs thoughts are on the right track to ferreting out truth or is on a spur track…
June 7th, 2006 at 11:50 pm
I’m just finding it difficult to find that so-called “mainstream media bias” these days (/sarc mode).
June 8th, 2006 at 1:33 pm
How our troops try to avoid civilian casualties (PM UPDATE I)…
The media relishes painting our military as a bunch of heartless thugs who don’t care about civilians in Iraq, but people who aren’t blinded by anti-war biases know otherwise. Examples follow.
Via Michael Yon:
We are facing a savage, savag…
June 8th, 2006 at 2:07 pm
MacDonald has set up a franchise of qaeda-linked reporters – including the ones who got shot last year for being a little “too close” to the action. They were so close, they were fighting on the other side.
That CJR link describes his “Reuniting And It Feels So Good” moment when some of them were returned after being jailed from US custody.